Can a case be reopened with new evidence?

Double jeopardy rules state that a person cannot be tried for the same crime twice. If new evidence surfaces that can prove that a convicted person is innocent, a case can be reopened. But, since Simpson was found innocent of this particular crime, the case cannot be reopened to prove that he is guilty. read more

Only evidence that is of a substantial nature will support a request for a new trial. If the evidence would likely have little effect on the outcome of the case, a motion for new trial will be denied. It has been discovered since trial. A court will not reopen a case or vacate a judgment unless the evidence has in fact been discovered. read more

It does not necessarily preclude the filing of a related suit based on other claims or new evidence, but it is incredibly unlikely (barring an appeal of the closure) that a case dismissed "with prejudice" would be reopened. read more