Is Eli Manning better than Peyton?

Our experts judge Eli and Peyton on their quarterbacking skills to determine which one is the better Manning. read more

Even if Eli's 8-3 postseason record is markedly better than Peyton's 9-11, it's an absurd sentiment from Barber. Eli was carried by his defensive line in Super Bowl XLII. He owes his first ring to Asante Samuel dropping the game-winning interception and David Tyree coming down with the most freakish reception in postseason history. read more

Our experts judge Eli and Peyton on their quarterbacking skills to determine which one is the better Manning. Our experts judge Eli and Peyton on their quarterbacking skills to determine which one is the better Manning. read more

Peyton is the superior QB, but Eli has played better when it matters Tiki has a point. Eli has been better in the postseason and has two rings to Peyton's one. That said, Peyton Manning is the better quarterback. In speaking to defensive coaches through the years, they have relayed to me that they fear Peyton a lot more than Eli. read more