What is the best place to eat pizza in Buffalo, NY?

01/18/2016. Johnny's Pizzeria & Restaurant · 19 reviews. #17 of 93 Results. $ Pizza Italian. “Solid pizza” 06/04/2017; “This pizzeria has been in the neighborh...” 07/10/2017. Joe's New York Style Pizza · 10 reviews. #18 of 93 Results. $ Italian Pizza. “Best pizza I have ever had!” 05/03/2017; “best pizza ever” 07/11/2017. read more

Hands down the best pizza in Buffalo is Mr. Pizza on Elmwood. I could eat a large cheese pepperoni myself. Their crust is as good as the toppings. Their pizza is made with the best of everything, real mozzarella and margherita pepperoni. read more

Thomas Gayvert: Buffalo chicken pizza was really nice. Had celery and carrots on it too for some crunch. Messie Jessie: New location same great pizza, beer and people. read more

Hands down the best pizza in Buffalo is Mr. Pizza on Elmwood. I could eat a large cheese pepperoni myself. Their crust is as good as the toppings. Their pizza is made with the best of everything, real mozzarella and margherita pepperoni. You can't even compare any of the “fake” franchise pizzerias to Mr. Pizza. read more

Xavier Guillaume: Best NY Style pizza in Buffalo! Get their Garlic Lover's Pizza or Tomato Basil Roma Pizza! Marco Navarra: Not my typical thin crust authentic neopalitan pizza; however, I had to visit this Bizarre Foods Delicious Destinations. read more