John Elway. Two Superbowl wins, a transformative figure in terms of his team and style of play, and truly made everyone around him better. Manning is an all time great, and no issues with him, but Elway was just incredibly special as a player, leader, icon and champion. read more
While Peyton is great and is a future HOF- John Elway led some of the best comebacks and is one of the best talents ever. He is a top 3 QB of all time. He played in more Superbowls than All the Mannings, Dan Marino, and Brett Favre combined. read more