Both musicians had different qualities, and both were excellent in their respective fields. John Coltrane was a virtuoso with his instrument. His technique and improvisation were superior to almost any other jazz musician. read more
Granted, the link above is from more of a subjective question but it highlights the main point I wanna bring to this answer- you can’t really compare the two. read more
Meanwhile in Philadelphia, John Coltrane, a tenor player not on Davis' short list but with a respectable – albeit local – reputation, was playing in organist Jimmy Smith’s combo. Philly Joe made Miles aware of his availability. read more