This is an interesting. Iceman is a mutant who has been described as either an Alpha or Omega-Level mutant. Johnny Storm is someone that I would describe as a proto- mutant, as his powers are in his genes, but only after his genetic code was radically rewritten by cosmic rays. read more
Ice man is a huge powerhouse, he just sucks at using his own powers. Human Torch is less powerful IMO, but embraces his powers more and is able to use them more fully, and because of that I think he would win. Iceman SHOULD win. Human Torch WOULD win. read more
If iceman were to continuely blast ice at torch, which would naturally melt, the water would extinguish him. Some might argue that human torch can melt iceman. that may be true but iceman has the ability to reassemble himself after going into a liquied form. If you look at the facts, the fight is in iceman's favor. read more
If the fight were held in a neutral atmosphere i.e. not too cold or too hot so neither could have an unfair advantage I believe the advantage would have to go the Human Torch. Iceman is very formidable and everything freezes. read more