Sonic, easily, if we are being faithful to both. His speed is formidable, he easily matches Mario's jumping capability, and his defense (rings) is much greater than Mario's (mushrooms). read more
Sonic, easily, if we are being faithful to both. His speed is formidable, he easily matches Mario's jumping capability, and his defense (rings) is much greater than Mario's (mushrooms). read more
If Sonic ran off, as is suggested by "Mario would never catch him", then Mario would win by default. Sonic isn't faster than Mario in a battle situation, only when moving long distance. Plus, Mario could become Mega Mario, Fire Mario, or find a star, and whoops, game over for Sonic. read more