Because it isn't part of New England. New England is made up of the states that were founded by religious immigrants fleeing persecution of the British crown, initially to Massachusetts. read more
The land north of it was claimed by England, thus, New England. New York wasn't part of the original New England, so it's not counted as such. There are a few who do count it as part of New England, but for the most part, Americans do not. read more
berkshires, boston, cape cod, chowder, clapboard, clapboard siding, connecticut, garden, landscape, lobster, lobster roll, lyme, maine, massachusetts, mount katahdin, mountains, new england, new england states, new england stone walls, new hampshire, old saybrook, pond, rhode island, stowe, the berkshires, the connecticut river, the green mountains, the new england, the white mountains, thimble islands, trees, vermont, white mountains, yankee, york. read more
Historically and Physically, they have many similarities to New England, especially Upstate New York and Western Pennsylvania, so why aren't they considered New England states. read more
Because it isn't part of New England. New England is made up of the states that were founded by religious immigrants fleeing persecution of the British crown, initially to Massachusetts. read more
New York, East Jersey, and West Jersey were added later. But since they were far from New England's capital in Boston, they were hard to control and generally were never really considered part of New England. The Dominion of New England was broken up by William and Mary. read more